Biography
Susan Cadogan
In 1974, a librarian in Kingston recorded a track in the legendary studio. A few months later, her voice dominated British radio stations. Susan Cadogan is this improbable story: the forgotten artist in Jamaica who became a lovers rock icon in the UK, with sporadic comebacks over fifty years.
In brief
| Full name | Alison Anne Cadogan (stage name: Susan Cadogan) |
| Birth | November 2, 1951, Kingston (Jamaica) |
| Field | Jamaican reggae and lovers rock singer |
| Notable works | “Hurt So Good”, Doing It Her Way, “Love Me Baby” |
| Awards | Silver-certified single (UK), gold (South Africa) |
Key dates
| Year | Event |
|---|---|
| 1951 | Born in Kingston, daughter of a Methodist pastor and a classical soprano |
| 1974 | First session at Lee Perry’s Black Ark; recording of “Hurt So Good” |
| 1975 | “Hurt So Good” reaches #4 on UK Singles Chart; appearances on Top of the Pops |
| 1975 | “Love Me Baby” reaches #22; album Doing It Her Way (Pete Waterman) |
| 1976 | Album Susan Cadogan (Trojan); return to librarian job |
| 1982 | Duo with Ruddy Thomas, #1 on UK Black Chart for eight weeks |
| 1989-1992 | Albums Chemistry of Love and Soulful Reggae (Mad Professor) |
| 2017-2018 | EP Take Me Back, album The Girl Who Cried (Burning Sounds) |
The Black Ark coincidence and the British twist
Alison Anne Cadogan grew up between two worlds: the Methodist church, where her father preached and her mother sang as a classical soprano, and soul records from her older sister. After years in Belize, she returned to Jamaica and became a librarian at the University of the West Indies, Mona.
In 1974, everything changed. A school friend, Theresa, knew Jerry Lewis, a JBC Radio DJ who had written her a song. Since Theresa was shy, it was Anne—nicknamed Susan—who sang in the studio at Black Ark. Lee “Scratch” Perry, the sound engineer that evening, was impressed. He offered the young woman to record a cover of Millie Jackson: “Hurt So Good”. “He asked me my name and I said, ‘I’m Anne Cadogan.’ He replied, ‘Susan is a sexier name.’” And he spelled it Suzanne on the record, she would later tell the Jamaica Observer.
The single was released on Perry’s Perries label, went unnoticed in Jamaica but exploded in the UK thanks to the DIP International imprint. Pete Waterman, who would later become a member of Stock Aitken Waterman, heard the track and proposed it to Magnet Records. “Hurt So Good” climbed to #4 on the UK Singles Chart in 1975, earned a silver certification in the UK and gold in South Africa. Cadogan flew to London, multiplied television appearances, including on Top of the Pops.
But a lawsuit erupted: Trojan Records, Perry’s label at the time, claimed rights. Magnet lost the original master but signed Cadogan and produced a new version with Waterman on the album Doing It Her Way (1975). The next single, “Love Me Baby”, reached #22—and remained her last UK hit. Subsequent singles on Klik and Lucky failed to break through.
“I didn’t receive much financially for my biggest success; she returned to her librarian job,” summarizes an interview.
Between two lives: music always on hold
After London, Susan Cadogan resumed her librarian life. Music awaited her: in 1981, she resurfaced and followed up local hits with covers of “Tracks of My Tears” and “Piece of My Heart”. In 1982, the duo with Ruddy Thomas, “You Know How to Make Me Feel So Good”, dominated the UK Black Chart for eight weeks. She won the JBC Radio Best Female Artist award. But she returned to work during the decade, only coming back into the studio in 1989 with the self-produced album Chemistry of Love, then in 1992 with Soulful Reggae on Ariwa Records, produced by the Mad Professor.
Around the turn of the millennium, Cadogan returned to the United States and recorded in Brooklyn with producer Glen Adams (Capo Records). Two albums were released in 2003: The Rhythm in You and Sincerely Susan. The 2010s saw a new wave: EP Take Me Back (2017, produced by Canadian Mitch Girio), album The Girl Who Cried (2018, Burning Sounds). She recorded a reggae duo with Ken Boothe, covers with the Italians The Magnetics, and an adaptation of Nat King Cole.
Cadogan has toured European stages since the 2000s, performing with The Slackers in New York, Portuguese Ratazanas, German Magic Touch, and Italian Magnetics. “I perform at least three times a year in Europe,” she once confessed. “If I had truly had the drive or support of a manager, I think I would have done much better. Music is a very complicated and unfair profession,” she added, still in this 2022 Jamaica Observer interview.
Major works
| Work | Year | Why it’s essential |
|---|---|---|
| “Hurt So Good” (single) | 1975 | #4 hit in the UK, certified silver and gold — lovers rock anthem |
| Doing It Her Way (album) | 1975 | Album produced by Pete Waterman in London with orchestra |
| “Love Me Baby” (single) | 1975 | Waterman successor, #22 UK; last British hit |
| Soulful Reggae (album) | 1992 | Return to pure reggae with the Mad Professor, Ariwa label |
| “You Know How to Make Me Feel So Good” (duo with Ruddy Thomas) | 1982 | Eight weeks at #1 on UK Black Chart — her voice still resonates |
Heritage and influence
The voice of Susan Cadogan, described by AllMusic as “oscillating between childlike innocence and burning sensuality”, made her an implicit reference for lovers rock singers, alongside Phyllis Dillon and Marcia Griffiths. Her atypical career — librarian by profession, singer by passion, absent but never gone — also tells the story of the unfair mechanisms of the Jamaican music industry: talents caught up in rivalries between labels.
“Hurt So Good” continues to resonate in DJ sets and reggae compilations. Fifty years after this madcap moment at the Black Ark, Susan Cadogan remains proof that the most beautiful voices in reggae are not always those we seek.
Sources and references
- “Susan Cadogan | Biography & History”, AllMusic, https://www.allmusic.com/artist/susan-cadogan-mn0000040114, accessed 26 November 2025.
- “Susan does it her way”, article by Kevin Jackson, Jamaica Observer, 15 March 2022, https://www.jamaicaobserver.com/2022/03/14/susan-does-it-her-way/, accessed 26 November 2025.
- “Hurt So Good” reggae star Susan Cadogan talks Top of the Pops", Portsmouth Echo, 8 June 2019, https://portsmouth.co.uk/whats-on/arts-and-entertainment/hurt-so-good-reggae-star-susan-cadogan-talks-top-of-the-pops-the-ramones-and-lee-scratch-perry-ahead-of-portsmouth-headline-show-interview-4174804, accessed 26 November 2025.
- Susan Cadogan, Wikipedia EN, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Susan_Cadogan, accessed 26 November 2025.
- Thompson, Dave (2002). Reggae & Caribbean Music. Backbeat Books. ISBN 0-87930-655-6.
- “Official Charts History”, Official Charts Company, https://www.officialcharts.com/search/singles/hurt-so-good/, accessed 26 November 2025.
- “Person notices – Cadogan, Susan”, Bibliothèque nationale de France, https://catalogue.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/cb13984639f, accessed 26 November 2025.
- “Susan Cadogan – Hurt So Good”, 45cat, https://www.45cat.com/record/mag23, accessed 26 November 2025.











